Since starting this blog in 2012, I have had a solid friend pool who have been very supportive of my crazy food quests (thanks guys!). But recently I have been thinking about engaging new palates and fresh perspectives, and to experiment with opening up my food quests to my social media followers.
So I asked Twitter if there were any aspiring food questers who have the stomach capacity and dedication to insanely devote a day of their lives to sampling every platter of nachos on Spring Garden Road.
The idea was actually Jenn’s (@jenngregoryDotC) of Jenn Gregory Photography. She said let’s do nachos and I said … let’s!
Also joining us from Twitter was Michael Dinn (@michaeldinn) of donair.org, Ben Jeddrie (@zyblonius), Laurie Burns (@lauriecburns), Denton Froese (@Labville), Vanessa Nickerson (@Prince_Lir), Richard (@mrdickmeadows), and the Halifax Wingman (@HalifaxWingman)!
We ordered a platter of nachos at every pub on Spring Garden Road. When available, we would order chicken and/or beef (usually as a half/half). We rated the nachos on these categories:
– Cheese Coverage
– Topping Distribution
– Size of dipping vessels
– Quality of salsa
– Quality of chips
– Adequate Layering
– Aesthetic Appeal
– Flavour Impression
– Perceived Value
– Platter Size
– Guacamole Inclusion
Michael Dinn requested a category for “Quality of Sour Cream” but I didn’t humour him. Instead, he basically demonstrated over the course of the nacho crawl that he can distinguish between different brands of sour cream. Meanwhile, I realized that I didn’t have a precise category for “Quality of Toppings” – but this will be reflected in the scores and discussed at length.
There was also a “Booze-O-Meter” (Vanessa’s idea!) on the scoring sheets so that participants could keep track of their beverage consumption. We had a fine mix of non-drinkers and heavy drinkers, so I believe the results are fairly reliable.
1) “Twice Fried Nachos” at The Arms
$13
“Almost perfect layering” – Halifax Wingman
Despite rebranding, The Arms has kept their famous “Twice Fried Nachos” on the menu. They are $13 and the menu does not mention any carnivorous add-ons.
We were a little confused about what “twice fried” meant, and it turns out it refers to the process of double layering and twice-baking. Perhaps “Twice Baked Nachos” would be more accurate. The group would have liked to see more cheese, but we were all impressed by the flavour imparted by the house-pickled banana peppers.
Opinions differed on the tri-coloured nacho chips. These are aesthetically pleasing, but tend to be rather neutral in flavour owing to a lack of salt. It is a matter of personal opinion.
For $13 this is a good portion size, and the platter scored first place in the category of “Perceived Value”.
2) “Great Nachos” at Your Father’s Moustache
$14.50
+ chicken or beef and side of guacamole ($19.50)
“A 6 dressed up as a 9″ – Michael Dinn
This platter looks cheesy and chunky, but as Michael Dinn notes, this is a “6 dressed up as a 9″. The large chicken chunks were that same wet chicken that I complained about when I wrote about the Pub Club. The beef was entirely unseasoned and tasted like boiled beef. Neither protein is worth the additional $3.50, which brings up the price to a whopping $18 ($19.50 with guac)!
Gotta love the patio, though…
3) 12 ” BBQ Nachos at Pizza Delight
$12.49
+ chicken ($15.99)
“Get the buffet, dummy!” – Richard
Pizza Delight’s nachos come in a 9″ and a 12″ skillet, and are drizzled with BBQ sauce.
I’m not the biggest fan of BBQ sauce, but it wasn’t the BBQ sauce that would make or break these nachos. It was the poor layering and cheese coverage. There was a pile of naked chips piled beneath the illusion of cheesy wealth.
With that said, the chips themselves scored the top mark! They were a golden blonde, toasty and warm.
Vanessa noted that the nachos “smell/taste like everything else at Pizza Delight”.
At $15.99 for a large nachos with chicken, the consensus was that the buffet is a much better value.
4) Nachos at The Fickle Frog
Sm $9 Lg $12
Small “Tropical” with Chicken: $12
Small “Classic” with Beef: $12
- Tropical nachos w/ chicken at The Fickle Frog
“An evening with nachos” – Denton
The Fickle Frog offers two types of nachos: “Tropical” (i.e. with pineapple), and “Classic”. You have the option of ordering a small or a large, so we ordered two smalls and put chicken on the Tropical nachos and beef on the classic. Makes sense.
The chicken was the wet processed stuff, cut into ungodly uniform chunks. But the pineapple was a nice touch. The other toppings were obviously the diced vegetables from the pizza bar and a little sprinkle goes a long way. The beef was spicy taco beef, like from an Old El Paso taco kit – which isn’t actually a bad thing…
- Classic nachos with spicy beef at The Fickle Frog
This was our first encounter with the notorious round nacho chips – disliked by many, but preferred by several questers for their saltiness and sturdiness.
Since we ordered smalls, it was hard to judge the layering. There could have been more cheese, and we would have appreciated sauce vessels that we could actually dunk our chips in… but otherwise this was a pleasant surprise. “The big surprise so far!”, wrote Denton, “Combined with the thunder mugs, it makes for a good pub experience”.
Michael was not a fan of the “Sobeys” salsa and thin, bland sour cream.
I think the general consensus was that these nachos are a good value, if not particularly memorable.
5) Nachos Grande at The Oasis
$9.99
+ chicken ($12.99)
“Everything’s sticky” – Vanessa
The “Nachos Grande” are described as: “Fresh house seasoned chips layered with mountains of cheese blend, onions, tomatoes, green and red peppers, jalapenos and marinated olives.”
“Looks good on paper,” Ben commented, “…but somehow the final product was underwhelming”.
The main problem was that the cheese not not melted enough and the nachos were lukewarm. These nachos had obviously not spent enough time in the oven.
The toppings were “even and populous”, as Richard observed, and the beef was better than at the Moustache, but not quite as flavourful as at the Fickle Frog. “Hey guys,” I interrupted, “This is real chicken” – and it was, indeed, the first time we were served chicken that appeared to be from an actual bird… even if it was a little dry.
For $10, the gang still considered this to be a good deal. That is… if you enjoy the Oasis atmosphere.
6) “Bubba’s Megga Nachos” at Bubba Ray’s
$15.99
+ chicken or beef ($18.98)
“Where’s the beef? It was here!” – Michael Dinn
Yes siree! The nachos at Bubba Ray’s came with this lovely pulled/stewed(?) beef that we just adored. The small diced chicken contributed to a good flavour distribution, if not an aesthetic appeal. This was the only place that did not charge us double for having half/half meats, so I give Bubba Ray’s some props for that. However, the portion was quite small for the price. It was certainly not “Mega” and actually quite average.
… $11.50 pitchers of Canadian, though…
7) Gourmet Nachos at Mexi Cali Rosa’s
“Super Nachos” ($11.99)
“Chipotle Chicken Nachos ($13.99)
Guacamole ($1.75)
- Super Nachos at Mexi Cali Rosa’s
“Thoughtfully placed for optics and taste” – Richard
Nachos are a specialty at Mexi Cali’s Rosa’s. There are 6 signature varieties from the spartan “Mexicali Nachos” to the elaborate “Chicken Wing Nachos”. These are small single-layer platters, so we ordered two varieties to get a proper sampling. The “Super Nachos” are your basic veggie nachos. They do not come with salsa but “Rosa’s red sauce” is colourfully drizzled around the platter.
The single-layer approach enables a “no chip left behind” mentality. Every chip is carefully and artfully adorned with a perfection of toppings, cheese and sauces.
- Chipotle Chicken Nachos at Mexi Cali Rosa’s
We also wanted to sample something a little more original – something that would showcase what Mexi Cali’s is truly capable of. Michael insisted on the “Chipotle Chicken Nachos” which come with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, bacon (BACON!), diced chicken and a honey chipotle sauce.
Both platters were exceptionally good. Not to mention the guacamole was out of this world! This is the only guacamole worth ordering on Spring Garden Road. Also, you can request a bottle of puréed jalapenos to kick up the heat a little bit. Everything is made in-house and entirely delicious. The only problem is that the platters are quite small – they are truly appetizer sized or an entrée for one.
Mexi Cali’s got the highest marks across the board, except for “Perceived Value” and “Size”.
I can’t recommend speak for the rest of the food at Mexi’s, but I am down with the roof top patio, the margaritas, the Bulldogs, and the amazing nachos!
8) “Rogue’s Nachos” at Rogue’s Roost
Sm $10.95 Lg $14.95
Lg + chicken or pulled pork and guacamole ($20.45)
“Nachos for the evening” – Denton
Rogue’s nachos were my stand-by going into the Quest, and as I predicated, the real crowd pleasers here are the cheese coverage and portion size. The nachos were actually kind of glued down by the cheese, but excavation revealed some empty chips. Despite a few imperfections, Rogue’s still got one of the highest marks for layering and placed #1 for portion size.
The flavours were adequate, in virtue of enough cheese and the round salty chips. We also really enjoyed the pulled pork option. Michael says the score for “Flavour Impression” is a 3/5, but the pulled pork is a 4.
The guacamole is simple “tube guac”. Not worth it.
These nachos aren’t much to look at, but they will feed a group without too many naked chips left at the bottom.
9) “Nachos” at Rock Bottom Brew Pub
$14.95
+ chicken ($17.95)
“Cheeseless depths…” – Denton
This was our last stop, as Rock Bottom does not open until 4pm on Sundays and we had to circle back (some of us quite intoxicated at this point). But we were coherent enough to notice that Rock Bottom somehow managed to serve us nachos that had naked chips on top of the pile. That is an impressive fail…
The best things about this platter were the chicken and the house-made salsa. Rock Bottom scored second place in the salsa category, trailing only behind Mexi Cali’s.
The sour cream also had Michael Dinn’s sour cream stamp of approval.
Overall, this is a small lackluster portion, which is too bad because Rock Bottom makes some of the best beer in the city!
Overall scores:
#1 Mexi Cali Rosa’s – 376
#2 The Arms -325
#3 Rogue’s Roost – 320
#4 Fickle Frog – 303.5
#5 Bubba Ray’s – 287
#6 Oasis – 274
#7 Your Father’s Moustache – 253.5
#8 Rock Bottom – 249.5
#9 Pizza Delight – 239
The Verdict:
Mexi Cali Rosa’s nachos are a league above the rest, with their gourmet nachos and home-made dips. Enjoy on the sunny patio with a margarita, Corona or Bulldog. Just keep in mind that the portions are small.
The Arms, located in the Lord Nelson Hotel, have a great deal going with a large layered platter of nachos with house-made banana peppers for $13. They also have a decent cocktail list featuring a Pimm’s Original and house-made clamato juice Caesars. The redesign is more upscale than the Victory Arms, so expect a slightly less casual environment.
Rogue’s Roost has what Denton describes as “Nachos for the evening”. If your party wants to sit down around a big plate of nachos and enjoy some craft beer – this is the place to go. Get the pulled pork. Avoid the guac.
Alternatively, The Fickle Frog is “An evening with nachos” – it is no nacho destination, but the nachos are an excellent choice when enjoying a 36oz steiner for $6.50 on Sundays! Get the Classic Nachos with beef, or the Tropical Nachos sans protein.