Investing Online II: Dick and Jane and insider trading

Dick* works for a small technology company on Canada’s East Coast.  He is a programmer, and spends much of his time working from home.

One day while reporting for a team meeting, he was surprised to find the office a-buzz with rumours about a possible corporate takeover. It was all still a secret he was told, but a major international technology firm was  apparently in negotiations with their board of directors. Everyone was wondering what it would mean locally: more investment and more jobs, or perhaps the opposite – cut backs and layoffs?

That evening over dinner, Dick discussed the situation with his sister Jane. While they decided things must be looking up if there was to be a takeover, and he needn’t worry about his job, Jane did bring up an interesting point.

“Don’t you earn stock options as a part of your compensation? I bet a takeover would drive the stock price up. You should buy now to take advantage of that.”

“Great idea, Jane,” said Dick. Why didn’t I think of that?”

The next day, Dick logged into his online account, and exercised his options, buying hundreds more shares in the company he worked for.

Six weeks later, the takeover was announced. Stock prices increased by about 40% in a few short weeks. Dick sold most of his shares to lock in a profit, and was quite excited. He even took Jane to dinner to celebrate their smart investing choices.

The next day, Dick was surprised to receive a call from the Securities Commission. They had questions about his recent account activity, and were investigating whether he acted on confidential insider information.

“I’m not an insider,” he thought. “I’m a programmer. Don’t those rules only apply to senior executives?”

What did Dick do wrong?

Securities laws prohibit a person in a special relationship with a reporting issuer from trading based on material information that is not available to the general public. By definition, an “insider” is someone in a position to know important, non-public information about a company, such as senior management.

However, anyone in an organization who becomes aware of such information,  such as research and development teams or public relations staff, can be considered as a person in a special relationship with the organization, and is not allowed to trade on that information until it is available to the public. These rules keep markets fair for all investors, as everyone is making choices based on the same information.

Dick and Jane were not aware of the rules regarding insider information, but lack of knowledge does not protect them. It is important for anyone investing on their own behalf to know that they are governed by the same laws as professional traders. Ensure that you are aware of the rules in your jurisdiction.

A good resource to start with is the Rule Book of the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (IIROC). Or, if you can handle the legal jargon, read the NS Securities Act.

You may also want to consider investing in more formal training – take a finance class at a university or community college, or sign up for the the Canadian Securities Course. It is a small investment for some valuable knowledge.

*Dick and Jane are fictional characters. The scenario however, is not that uncommon.

More Meeples


and the dog jumped over the moon….